George Monbiot, The Guardian 25 June 2012.

So now what do we do to defend life on Earth?

 

By George Monbiot, published in the Guardian 25th June 2012

It is, perhaps, the greatest failure of collective leadership since the first world war. The Earth’s living systems are collapsing, and the leaders of some of the most powerful nations – the US, the UK, Germany, Russia – could not even be bothered to turn up and discuss it. Those who did attend the Earth summit last week solemnly agreed to keep stoking the destructive fires: sixteen times in their text they pledged to pursue “sustained growth”, the primary cause of the biosphere’s losses(1)…

http://www.monbiot.com/2012/06/25/end-of-an-era/

Categories: Eskom, General News

by Tina Schubert

Share

Categories: Eskom, General News

by Tina Schubert

Share

By Lisa Isaacs Time of article published Apr 9, 2021

Environment Minister Barbara Creecy is expected to make a final decision on granting Eskom permission to build a new nuclear plant in Duynefontein. File picture: African News Agency (ANA)
Environment Minister Barbara Creecy is expected to make a final decision on granting Eskom permission to build a new nuclear plant in Duynefontein. File picture: African News Agency (ANA)

Cape Town – Civil organisations have slammed Eskom’s response to the Nuclear-1 Environmental Authorisation (EA) appeal over permission to build a new nuclear plant at the Koeberg site.

Eskom released its response to the EA appeal on April 1, marking the last step before Environment Minister Barbara Creecy is expected to make a final decision on granting Eskom permission to build a new plant in Duynefontein, the Koeberg Alert Alliance said.

They charged that Eskom’s response contained misinformation and pushed for a new nuclear build, overriding the country’s energy plan, the Integrated Resource Plan of 2019 (IRP 2019).

The alliance said in 2007 Eskom planned to build three large nuclear plants in South Africa for which an Environmental Impact Assessment process was required by law.

The first Environmental Impact Report (EIR) was completed by 2010 and submitted to the Department of Environmental Affairs (DEA).

The EIR was revised three times and in 2017 the DEA Minister granted an EA for a plant at the Koeberg site prompting organisations and individuals to appeal the decision by the deadline in March 2018.

In July last year, the DEA issued an invitation for supplementary submissions as the 2010 IRP had since been replaced by the Integrated Resource Plan 2019.

While the parastatal did not respond to questions yesterday, in its appeal response, Eskom submits that “it would be procedurally unfair and prejudicial for an appeal authority to treat the IRP 2019 as a relevant consideration to its decision whether to uphold or to dismiss the appeal”.

In publishing the IRP 2019, Cabinet clearly believed that a nuclear programme could be implemented in a flexible and cost-effective manner, Eskom said.

“The IRP 2019 recognises additional nuclear capacity of 2500MW contributing to the South African energy mix. The country’s policy-makers have taken a decision to go ahead with nuclear, as part of South Africa’s energy mix. It is not for Eskom or the DEFF to question the policy-makers’ decision.”

They also argued that nuclear energy did not emit greenhouse gases.

Koeberg Alert Alliance spokesperson Peter Becker said: “The entire EIA depended on the need and desirability of the project as outlined in the IRP 2010. This has changed in the IRP 2019, and it is ridiculous that Eskom are trying to convince us that a decision should be made based on an 11-year-old plan.”

Richard Halsey, a researcher at Project 90 by 2030, said there was no evidence to back up the need for a new nuclear plant.

“All objective energy modelling points in the opposite direction, indicating that new nuclear is not an optimal or least-cost option for South Africa,” said Halsey.

Earthlife Africa’s programmes officer, Ulrich Steenkamp, said nuclear energy was not the answer to climate change as it was completely carbon intensive.

Cape Times

STAY IN THE LOOP

Subscribe to our free newsletter.

Business Report 1 July 2012. Optimal Energy chief executive Kobus Meiring is a disappointed man. The company is the developer of South Africa’s electric car but it officially closed on Friday with the loss of about 60 jobs. This follows its failure to get further funding from the government and the Industrial Development Corporation (IDC)... http://www.iol.co.za/business/business-news/why-sa-s-electric-car-is-not-going-anywhere-1.1331580#.T_E37xcjGq8

Related Posts

  • Tangled web of Eskom has little to do with electricity By MJ (Thinus) Booysen  Follow 14 Dec 2022  2 Professor MJ (Thinus) Booysen is Research Chair in Internet of Things and Director of the MTN Mobile Intelligence Research Laboratory in the Faculty of Engineering, Stellenbosch University: www.thinus.co.za The technical and economic challenges in South Africa’s energy crisis […]

  • After the Bell: The way people misunderstand renewable power is shocking  (Image: iStock) By Tim Cohen  Follow 13 Dec 2022  2 I can’t get away from the feeling that the constant, relentless defence of coal has a larger agenda somewhere behind it. Listen to this article 0:00 / 6:23 1X BeyondWords How do we comprehend the resistance among […]

  • Opinion: Koeberg life extension could flip switch on half a trillion rands of economic damage Graphic showing coal capacity factors and loadshedding 24TH NOVEMBER 2022 ARTICLE ENQUIRY      SAVE THIS ARTICLE      EMAIL THIS ARTICLE FONT SIZE: –+ In this opinion article, energy analyst and commentator Clyde Mallinson warns that, against the backdrop of persistent and erratic loadshedding, the economic cost of shutting the Koeberg nuclear plant for […]

  • A New Barefoot GuideFrom the Agroecology Series My Food is African Healthy soil, safe foods and diverse diets Télécharger – Français Download – E   A New Barefoot Guide From the Agroecology Series My Food is African Healthy soil, safe foods and diverse diets Télécharger – Français Download – English A publication of The Alliance […]

Go to Top